While we will never know how the IMB Presidential Search Committee arrived at their choice of Dr. Eliff, he is part of the establishment within the SBC. There has been much speculation (see Stephen's link to the discussion at SBCVoices), but this may have been a consensus choice that the entire committee could unanimously agree on. He may serve a long time, but it would surprise no one if he was a "caretaker" for 5-10 years until someone else took over.
As to Stephen's not being able to imagine the new IMB President not being Ronnie Floyd, I assume Stephen is seriously wondering. For those not as involved in SBC life and/or politics, Ronnie Floyd's nomination would have resulted in mass rebellion and all-out war within the Convention. As it is, there are cracks in the foundation that continue to grow deeper and wider (see my post
http://www.fromlaw2grace.com/2011/02/17 ... foundation). If the GCR is fully implemented, then I believe that the collapse of the SBC, as we now know it, is inevitable. Floyd's nomination would have been the equivalent of a massive earthquake. Thanks and God bless,