Backlash against the religious right?

Open discussion on general Baptist-related topics of interest to Baptists around the world.

Moderator: Dave Roberts

Re: Backlash against the religious right?

Postby Ed Pettibone » Thu Apr 19, 2012 5:27 am

Tim Bonney wrote:
Ed Pettibone wrote:
While some scars can never be made "right". It is also true that a wound will not heal if one keeps picking at it.


All I can say Ed is if you've not been there you don't have a clue. If you've been in a toxic church then you know what it is about. If you haven't you can't imagine. And what you are doing today, wittingly or unwittingly, is attack Gene and I in ways that I no longer tolerate or accept from anyone. Chinmoku.


Ed: One less adversarial former Baptist friend on BLC . But as a parting shot, Tim I will say I have been there, but more of my suffering was at the hands of clergy than Laity. And I also had some good Baptist Clergy type Professors that helped me get past (through, not over) the pain. I pray you will get through yours.
User avatar
Ed Pettibone
 
Posts: 10263
Joined: Thu Aug 12, 2004 4:46 pm
Location: .Burnt Hills, New York, Capital Area

Re: Backlash against the religious right?

Postby Dave Roberts » Thu Apr 19, 2012 7:01 am

As forum moderator, I want to speak a public word to both Ed and Gene:

We all get stuck in our past experiences. I know both of you personally, and I am asking that you give each other a little more latitude and respect. I have not walked in the same circumstances in which either of you has walked, but I have been through toxic church pain before. What you both need is to give each other a little more patience and remember you are brothers in Christ. I respect you both as friends, and ask that you ease the rhetoric on each other.
"God will never be less than He is and does not need to be more" (John Koessler)

My blog: http://emporiadave.wordpress.com/
User avatar
Dave Roberts
Site Admin
 
Posts: 5203
Joined: Thu Aug 12, 2004 2:01 pm
Location: Southside, VA

Re: Backlash against the religious right?

Postby William Thornton » Thu Apr 19, 2012 7:11 am

Well put, Dave.

I appreciate the material contributions here of both Ed and Gene.
My stray thoughts on SBC stuff may be found at my blog, SBC Plodder
User avatar
William Thornton
Site Admin
 
Posts: 9339
Joined: Thu Aug 12, 2004 10:30 pm
Location: Atlanta

Re: Backlash against the religious right?

Postby Timothy Bonney » Thu Apr 19, 2012 7:46 am

William Thornton wrote:Well put, Dave.

I appreciate the material contributions here of both Ed and Gene.


When Ed contributed "materially" I appreciated that. When Ed finds someone's wound, even and old one as in Gene's case, and seeks to poke it with a stick then the appreciation stops.
Timothy Bonney, OSL
Senior Pastor
Grace UMC
Sioux City, Iowa
Church Website: http://gracesiouxcity.org
My blog: http://circuitwriter.org
User avatar
Timothy Bonney
Site Admin
 
Posts: 2405
Joined: Wed Sep 28, 2011 10:17 am
Location: Sioux City, Iowa

Re: Backlash against the religious right?

Postby Ed Pettibone » Thu Apr 19, 2012 8:41 am

Mrs H. I think I understand what you said to Gene but see my reply to Tim Bonney. I have indeed experienced toxic religion. I put off making a profession of faith until I was an adult because of my close observation of church folk, Clergy and Laity. I did not grow up as a preachers Kid either.
although my parents had both been licensed to preach.

I will try to make a long story short. Some how my dad became involved with a waiters at a restaurant where he delivered bread, pies and rolls.
when she learned about it my mother went to he pastor and his wife. Immediately they started arranging for her to leave my dad and soon it seemdd the whole church knew about the problem. My mother wanted to at least try to work on reconciliation. She was told that to reconcile she would have to forgive AND that if she forgave him for such a sin she would be as bad as he was. She went along with their advice and filed for divorce. And I went to live with my grandparents who attended the same type of church. My mother stayed in the same type of church. And I became "that divorced woman's little boy". Tim Bonney nor you or anyone else needs to tell me about toxic churches.

Years latter and and God caused me to cross paths with Black baptist Chaplin in Korea when out of boredom I attended a service in which he preached about love and forgiveness. And since we where there on a "Peace Keeping Mission" (1955) I had a lot of spare time I attended chapel rather frequently. I drove the Chaplain around a lot and we talked a LOT. Soon our outfit was shipped to Japan and we did not unpack for three months and had no regular duty assignments so I became an unofficial chaplains assistant even though I did not claim to be a Christian. He decided to have A revival on base ( we where assigned to a navel station even though we where Army. We some time joked that the Army had lost us. We where a regimental HQ & HQ company but most of the regiment was still in Korea. Eventually the Revival Services where held and I made a genuine profession of faith. One thing led to another and one day he aske what I was going to do when I got out of service and i told him about my plans to go back to work at GE untill I had saved enough to move to Chicago to study stage management and to mary the Nursing student back in the states to whom I was "tentatively" engaged to marry. HE asked if I had an interest in preaching and I said "I have thought about it But that girl back home was a PK and she wants nothing to do with being a preachers wife. Then we shipped back to Korea ( had never unpacked our gear). It was close to the end of my overseas tour. And the Major and I talked a lot about denominations I might consider. He was rather insistent that I find a Southern Baptist church that sounded strange to me because my girl friends father was a bivocational So Baptist preacher and had gotten into some serious conflict with his association and his church because of his friendship with several black co-workers on the Oak Ridge Project.

I did marry that young woman and we moved to Birmingham Alabama for me to enter college as a Ministerial Student. The first year, we got into a great Church with a terrific Pastor. Then we went to a small country church to help a student friend of mine who was the pastor pastor. Those folk tolerated me because my buddy was from Georgia I had met him in his home church while I was stationed at Ft. Benning. And they knew nothing of my civil rights activity. Ron graduated and the School relocated to the other side of B'ham and although I did OK with most of my classes, I flunked out of Howard through the English Department. And went to work in the personnel department of the hospital where my wife was employed eventually We went to Newton Mississippi and a small Baptist college for me to get my English out of the way. We almost immediately got sideways with the community because we over paid our "Colored girl". And I defended a Sociology professor who most of my fellow ministerial students felt was "Teaching too much sex in a mixed class room". The chapter that really got him into trouble was titled Sexual deviation. He got fired and went to teach at a Fine Methodist School in B'ham. And it was while there that I went on a supply preaching assignment In Philadelphia Ms. and upset the chair of deacons by referring to the chorus "Red and yellow, black and white they are precious in his sight". Our church history professor was one of the few people I got along well with and he sometimes had me preach in his church. We attended the FBC there and those folk treated us pretty well except for one deacon who advised the others not to "worry about that Yankee boy, cause he will soon move on and be somebody else's problem" Have I made my case about experiencing toxic churches and Toxic Baptist. or should I go on with the next 50 years. That was only 5 and just skimmed the top. :brick: Honestly it did get better. :) :) When I discovered the difference in ignorance, prejudice and pride. After more hurts and a lot of recovery. Should I feel Sorry for G.S. perhaps, but I am sure their is more to his stories than we have heard and his side hasn't reached my hart strings. Oh Yea! I tried that worshiping in nature bit, that is how I got into Long distance bicycling. Indy to Atlanta, Indy to St Louis, Indy to little Rock and several one day centuries. Dropped out of church of a while after a divorce. Got back into church through singles ministry. My Second wife has served in three settings one very discouraged church, a dual parish of very tired people, and a rather overwhelmed congregation but never a sick church . They are churches that have had, both very good pastors and some who must surly have missed their call.

Ed: And Dave R. I respect your request but I do not and will not countenance Genes Continued crude language. And if he must have a pity party ask him to give is some new material. And I still contend that picking wounds is not healthy or a way to get healthy. Now I have to get ready to take Trudy for a 2nd biopsy. See you all this afternoon.
User avatar
Ed Pettibone
 
Posts: 10263
Joined: Thu Aug 12, 2004 4:46 pm
Location: .Burnt Hills, New York, Capital Area

Re: Backlash against the religious right?

Postby Gene Scarborough » Thu Apr 19, 2012 8:49 am

Thanks for the empathy, folks!

I am enjoying the lack of Baptists here in Bath---and the plenteous water and fresh air! The plenteous Churches of Christ here have the same issues as do most Baptist churches, plenteous across most of NC.

I have no idea why Ed is being so surly right now. We are all praying for Trudy in these anxious days. He has every right to be more emotional right now and I continue my prayers for his attitude to be more compassionate.

Despite the awful treatment given my father when he faced off with a crooked mayor / church treasurer / bully at a church. That church was growing faster than ever because of his touch in reaching people for Christ, I felt a call to ministry when I was applying for grad school in Psychology. For once, I had a Pastor who had some intelligence which the typical SBC preacher seem often to lack. I had sworn I would never subject myself or my family to what had happened to ours.

He asked me a question I could not shake: "What will happen to the church if some of you intelligent and gifted young people desert it?"

I had just taken the GRE and noted on the scale that I was a 50 percentile in Psychology and a 90% in Clergy. That accurate predictor / analysis test showed me I could be a gifted Pastor and average Psychologist. I enjoyed my 1970-86 full-time ministry in 2 Associate positions and 4 Senior MInister positions. Our children were getting to their teens and deserved not moving every 3-5 years as Baptist Pastors often do. I became bi-vocational as I started my Insurance career with Ministers LIfe and was covering all of Eastern, NC, for them. It was wonderful to do both ministry in church and ministry in insurance.

I was also watching the CR Takeover and was living only 45-minutes from my beloved SEBTS. The rise of the religious right and the Takeover were synonymous with the move to Conservative Repubicanism in the political South. I fail to see any of it as a plus. In my view it is nothing but hate and too much reaction to integration plus rapid changes in society. In a way, it is the height of hipocracy to me. It is a refusal to adapt to change nor apply the truths of Christ to changing society entraped with the choke-hold of conservative religion.

This "pretense of success" has led to this economic crash and the rise of the mega church. We have lost too much compassion for the poor and needy as we drive nice cars to nice churches and put in new organs when the slums next door creep closer and closer to fine church buildings.

I do not like "glorified social clubs" with church names on them. I rebel even more when those leading the churches are doing it with the same pretense done with my father's church and 2 I served. Plain speeking is seldom welcome these days---especially when it convicts the people of the betrayal of Christ's love to all.

This is a place where we can debate and share. With my work slow, it makes the days pass with good discussion. As a small businessman I am experiencing, first hand, the angst of American economics. How many of those pastoring churches have had their salary reduced to reflect what is happening to most people in the congregation?
Gene Scarborough
Gene Scarborough
 
Posts: 3065
Joined: Thu Apr 08, 2010 5:54 pm
Location: Bath, NC

Re: Backlash against the religious right?

Postby Timothy Bonney » Thu Apr 19, 2012 9:07 am

Gene Scarborough wrote:This is a place where we can debate and share. With my work slow, it makes the days pass with good discussion. As a small businessman I am experiencing, first hand, the angst of American economics. How many of those pastoring churches have had their salary reduced to reflect what is happening to most people in the congregation?


A lot actually Gene. I know of multiple UMC churches that either cut salaries or waited until the next pastoral move and lowered the salary for the new pastor due to economics. Churches and their employees are feeling the pinch just as in other industry.

Ed's idea that there has to basically be "two to tango" doesn't work in a toxic church situation. it takes two to have a conflict but it only takes one person (or group) to choose to sabotage a church's ministry for their own gain. Often these groups don't every allow open conflict.

I remember the very first church I pastored out of seminary. There was a guy who attended there that bragged that he had chased off the last three pastors. Their mode of operation was to chase off the pastor every three years like clock work. Basically as soon as the pastor was there long enough to get a following and start acting like the leader of the church this guy and his cronies would feel threatened and would start a campaign of slander and disinformation to cause the pastor to want to leave. There was no "conflict" because those chasing off the preacher always did it all behind everyone's back and by the time you figured out what they were doing too much damage was done.

I was their 10th pastor in 30 years. After I left they called a previous pastor and asked him to be interim. His response was "shut down the church, close the doors and start over because there ain't no fixing this place."

There are certainly pastors who cause trouble in churches. I've seen that too. But the reality is that there are sick, toxic and chronically dysfunctional churches that shouldn't get a pastor. Often when they chase off enough people they get a reputation and have trouble getting a pastor. So this church called green pastors straight out of seminary who didn't know enough questions to ask until it was too late.

It was quite a learning experience to say the least!
Timothy Bonney, OSL
Senior Pastor
Grace UMC
Sioux City, Iowa
Church Website: http://gracesiouxcity.org
My blog: http://circuitwriter.org
User avatar
Timothy Bonney
Site Admin
 
Posts: 2405
Joined: Wed Sep 28, 2011 10:17 am
Location: Sioux City, Iowa

Re: Backlash against the religious right?

Postby Gene Scarborough » Thu Apr 19, 2012 9:18 am

This is becoming one of the most interesting threads I have ever entered. The value of people surrounding 2 hurting participants literally brings tears of joy to my eyes right now.

Ed and I were both typing our testimony at the same time above. When I punched the "submit" button, Ed's entry was posted and I had no chance to read it until I was privately typing my own = what a coincidence.

Our stories are of 2 men with a sense of integrity being run over by people pretending to be followers of Christ in a church best described as a "glorified social club." That happens far too often.

Both of us have been hurt to the core and speak as honestly as we can out of these hurts. We are joined by others who have surrounded us. Each supporter gives a hint of similar hurts. I think we come away from such by admitting they happen even in supposed "fellowships of love."

Like Ed, I give myself body and soul to whatever endeavor I undertake. I am frustrated by the fact that, after years of dedicated hard work, the economy tanked in the case of Tree Surgery. Any new businessman expects 5-10 years of starvation to get established. Just as my business was growing in its 7th year---here comes the Recession / lost house to foreclosure / change of location / struggles just to keep the lights on.

Despite the hardships, I am rewarded by wonderful children and grandchildren. They have their issues with organized religions these days, but are solidly spiritual people. Therefore, I don't believe organized religion is "essential." I note that, with both Ed and me, an outstanding individual associated with organized religion touched us!

I have sent a PM to Ed and we will privately carry on any divisive discussions. I note he and Trudy are headed to the Doctor again---so I concentrate my prayers by the River for good reports and healing as well as happiness.

This is a wonderful group of people to call "good friends who think deep." :)
Last edited by Gene Scarborough on Thu Apr 19, 2012 9:34 am, edited 1 time in total.
Gene Scarborough
Gene Scarborough
 
Posts: 3065
Joined: Thu Apr 08, 2010 5:54 pm
Location: Bath, NC

Re: Backlash against the religious right?

Postby Gene Scarborough » Thu Apr 19, 2012 9:30 am

Tim---

Been there / done that!!!!

It is my conclusion that too many laymen have a call to preach and reject it to become a church leader. They are full of self-depreciation over failure to comply with God's calling and take it out on any Pastor who comes into their gunsights. In both churches which fired me, this was the case.

The real problem is as you cited: too much talk and destruction behind the back of the Pastor (their sacrificial goat).

I am convinced, like you, that if a church has just become a "glorified social club" it does not deserve fresh meat to hurt = shut it down! Healthy churches normally have 1-3 good and solid Christian practicioners who help resolve problems over stirring them to critical mass. They spot trouble and get the potential fight stopped by getting the individuals together as Jesus advocated. The whole purpose is reconciliation of people to people and people to God!

I served in such a capacity as I entered the Insurance Profession and we joined the church in which we were married and my wife's family were charter members. Had I not taken a solid week chasing the individuals and problems privately and then getting them all together, that church would have had an ugly and gossiping total blow up! It takes more courage and time to solve problems than it does to let them happen.
Gene Scarborough
Gene Scarborough
 
Posts: 3065
Joined: Thu Apr 08, 2010 5:54 pm
Location: Bath, NC

Re: Backlash against the religious right?

Postby Ed Pettibone » Thu Apr 19, 2012 4:55 pm

Ed: Gene I appreciate your latest post. Maybe this can develop into something. HOWEVER, I do not do any thing except social planning with participants of BL.C via PM's. And I prefer to do the social stuff including preaching invites and retirement parties on the board or via E-mail.

I may be retire but I do not have enough hours in the day to go baklashing against any group on the other end of the state, the nation or other side of the world. I am persuaded that there are even quite a few good people on the religious right, that does not mean i think they are always RIGHT.
User avatar
Ed Pettibone
 
Posts: 10263
Joined: Thu Aug 12, 2004 4:46 pm
Location: .Burnt Hills, New York, Capital Area

Re: Backlash against the religious right?

Postby Gene Scarborough » Thu Apr 19, 2012 5:19 pm

Thanks, Ed----we don't have to be enemies now since we both know some important background detail.

I hope Trudy got good reports and our prayers for healing will all be answeredd! :)
Gene Scarborough
Gene Scarborough
 
Posts: 3065
Joined: Thu Apr 08, 2010 5:54 pm
Location: Bath, NC

Previous

Return to Baptist Faith & Practice Forum

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot], James and 4 guests