Sorry Blake, but I think you and I are wasting our time. You can't seem to help that you are arguing out of a Baptist or maybe Anabaptist context which does not at all fit my theological context. Even your most recent post can't help but quote only rather conservative Baptist authors as the backing for your argument.
Stetzer and McKnight aren't authorities for me and weren't when I was still a progressive American Baptist rather than a progressive Methodist. Their conservative brand of Baptist never appealed to me much.
Your notion that orthodoxy and orthopraxy are a false dichotomy sounds like it should be true. But I see a large swath of persons of evangelical faith groups who quite purposefully place orthodoxy as the highest ideal and deemphasize orthopraxy almost entirely. Yes, they should be false dichotomies but they are not in quite a few Christian faith groups where right belief is emphasized above right action almost exclusively.