Truth about DACA

The place to discuss politics and policy issues that are not directly related to matters of faith.

Moderator: Jon Estes

Truth about DACA

Postby KeithE » Thu Jan 25, 2018 9:15 am

Got this from a Friend.

14 Things You Probably Didn’t Know About DACA
1. DACA recipients are not eligible to vote (and they never will be). DACA is not a path to citizenship or amnesty. It simply shields them temporarily from being deported because as children, they were brought to the US illegally by their parents by no fault of their own. It is not a liberal conspiracy for capturing future Democratic votes. They will never be citizens.
2. DACA recipients do not receive free healthcare, welfare, or food stamps. They are not even eligible for Obamacare or Medicaid.
DACA recipients are required to pay income taxes. It’s estimated that ending DACA would decrease state and local revenue by $800 million a year.
3. DACA recipients are not just "too lazy" or "too busy" to take the proper steps to legal citizenship. Once they are approved for the DACA program, they will never be eligible for any other legal status in the US other then "DACA," even if they are married to US citizens. As the law stands now, the option to become a US citizen will simply never be made available to them. The program is only meant to be temporary protection from the deportation and a chance to live, work and obtain a driver’s license legally in the US. Nothing more. It's not just a matter of walking up to a desk somewhere at City Hall, filling out an application and reciting the Pledge of Allegiance.
4. The United States is the only home they have ever known. If they were to be deported, they will be sent to a country they have never seen or known. Most often, their parents fled a country suffering from severe poverty, war, and oppression. Bringing their children to the US, even with the serious risks of doing it illegally, may have been their parent's only hope. Everyone wants the best for their children.
5. DACA recipients speak English and are very often bilingual. For the most part, they are completely assimilated in American culture. Some don’t even realize that they are not in the country legally until they are old enough to need a driver’s license and a job. It is often devastating and embarrassing for them to suddenly find out they are “illegal.”
6. DACA Recipients cannot have a criminal record and will be deported if they don’t adhere to some very strict rules. Saying they are “mostly violent criminals and gang members” is unequivocally false. If they screw up, they have to leave the country.
7. To be granted DACA status, they must pass a background check, have a clean criminal record and a high school diploma or GED. They lose their eligibility if they commit a felony or a significant misdemeanor. Even a regular misdemeanor, juvenile adjudication, or expunged conviction can put them at severe risk for eligibility. (And for the record, the incarceration rate of native born American citizens is 14% higher than DACA recipients as a whole.)
8. DACA recipients are not stealing your jobs. Over 6 million jobs remain unfilled in the United States, a record high, despite 90% of DACA recipients being employed.
9. The DACA program has been overwhelmingly successful for the US economy. It is estimated that the US would lose $460 billion dollars in GDP over the next 10 years without DACA. The majority of recipients buy cars, houses, and other large purchases that contribute to strong economic growth. We need them.
10. DACA recipients live in fear and uncertainty. They must reapply for DACA status every 2 years for the rest of their lives. It costs at least $500 every time they apply. It's a stressful, uncertain life considering they are penalized for something they had no control over.
11. Over 72% either have advanced degrees or are enrolled in higher education. Contrary to popular belief, they are not instantly rewarded a free college tuition. It is true that many opportunities are made available to them, such as scholarships, in-state tuition, and in some cases financial aid, to encourage them to further their education. A better education means they are better contributors to their communities.
12. DACA stands for the "Deferred Action Childhood Arrivals" program. They are also affectionately called "Dreamers" after the "Dream Act" which stands for "Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors." Recipients must be under the age of 31 as of June 15, 2012, and must have come to the US before reaching 16.
13. More than 1800 Governors, attorneys general, mayors, state representatives, police chiefs, and judges have signed onto a letter supporting DACA.
14. Sadly, DACA has been put on the chopping block by the Trump administration and its future looks bleak. Donald Trump, Attorney General Jeff Sessions, as well as Fox News, Brietbart, and other Right Wing "media" outlets are successfully leading the way on stoking serious fear about DACA to the American public. Not only are they trying to end DACA, they're trying to end several other LEGAL immigration programs and laws. They want to hand pick what nationalities will be considered for immigration to the US. Call your representatives today and let them know you insist on the DACA program to be continued.
Please feel free to share widely!

A. Official Website of the Department of Homeland Security:
B. "Key Facts About Unauthorized Immigrants Enrolled in DACA" September, 2017 Cato Institute.
C. Immigration, Research and Policy Brief, August 2017 Center for American Progress October, 2016
D. Newsweek “DACA by the Numbers” August, 2017
E. CNN "DACA Myths Debunked" October, 2017 CNBC "DACA Deportations Could Cost US Economy More Than 400 $ Billion" September, 2017
F. CNN "DACA Dreamers Immigration Program Explained" October, 2017
G. Pew Research (unspecified)
Sorry it does not say which source was used for which of the 14 “things".

A question came up about the parenthetical statement in red above (about DACAers never being able to vote).
From Ellin Jimmerson (commenting on this):
I think I knew where the confusion is. First, DACA and citizenship are not related. DACA (If you read the memo) did not in and of itself provide a pathway to citizen nor confer any legal status. That does not mean that there were not other paths to a legal status or to citizenship.

and in another comment
So, in response, a big-hearted woman in Alabama spent simply ages (12 hours!) reading everything but the DACA memo itself to come up with the dubious (i.e. fake) news idea that DACA recipients are barred from citizenship and voting FOREVER! and will spend the REST OF THEIR LIVES! reapplying for extension after extension after extension of DACA.

So I suspect she does not agree with the parenthetical statement in red in 1. above. I believe her; and the parenthetical statement should have been something like (and they never will be, as long as they are enrolled in DACA).

FWIW (and it is not worth much):
Informed by Data.
Driven by the SPIRIT and JESUS’s Example.
Promoting the Kingdom of GOD on Earth.
User avatar
Site Admin
Posts: 9024
Joined: Thu Aug 12, 2004 8:02 pm
Location: Huntsville, AL

Return to Politics and Public Policy Issues

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest